Difference between revisions of "Libertarians Criticizing Each Other"
From Critiques Of Libertarianism
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<!-- you can have any number of categories here --> | <!-- you can have any number of categories here --> | ||
[[Category:Criticism]] | [[Category:Criticism]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Ideology|800]] | ||
{{DES | des = Libertarianism is full of schisms over numerous philosophical and political points. We hardly need invent criticisms when libertarians create them plentifully to argue with each other. | show=}} | {{DES | des = Libertarianism is full of schisms over numerous philosophical and political points. We hardly need invent criticisms when libertarians create them plentifully to argue with each other. | show=}} | ||
| + | <!-- insert wiki page text here --> | ||
In particular: | In particular: | ||
* Abortion rights. | * Abortion rights. | ||
* Has the US government initiated coercion enough that the Libertarian Party Pledge licenses revolt? | * Has the US government initiated coercion enough that the Libertarian Party Pledge licenses revolt? | ||
| − | * | + | * Consequentialism or natural rights (a priori) reasoning? |
| + | * [[Non-Aggression]] or other principles? | ||
| + | * Is [[Self-Ownership]] valid? | ||
| + | * Is [[Slavery]] valid? | ||
| + | * Is liberty a value or a right? | ||
* Religion or atheism? | * Religion or atheism? | ||
* Objectivism or libertarianism? | * Objectivism or libertarianism? | ||
| − | * Austrian economics or | + | * Austrian economics or Chicago economics? |
* Is [[Intellectual Property Reform|Intellectual Property]] valid? | * Is [[Intellectual Property Reform|Intellectual Property]] valid? | ||
* No government or minimal government? | * No government or minimal government? | ||
| + | * Constitution of the US good or bad and why? | ||
| + | * Georgist taxes or not? | ||
* Just what should be in a minimal government? | * Just what should be in a minimal government? | ||
* Are taxes justified to pay for school vouchers? | * Are taxes justified to pay for school vouchers? | ||
* Should immigration be free or restricted? | * Should immigration be free or restricted? | ||
| + | * Thick versus thin libertarianism? | ||
| + | * Rationalist versus antirationalist? | ||
* "No True Libertarian would...." (The No True Scotsman Fallacy) | * "No True Libertarian would...." (The No True Scotsman Fallacy) | ||
| + | * Koch allied or Rothbard allied? | ||
| + | * For or against the Libertarian Party? | ||
* Purges within Objectivism, the Libertarian Party, The Cato Institute and other libertarian organizations for not following the party (or management) line. | * Purges within Objectivism, the Libertarian Party, The Cato Institute and other libertarian organizations for not following the party (or management) line. | ||
| + | * Left or right libertarian? | ||
The list goes on and on.... | The list goes on and on.... | ||
| − | {{Links}} | + | <!-- DPL has problems with categories that have a single quote in them. Use these explicit workarounds. --> |
| − | {{Quotes}} | + | <!-- otherwise, we would use {{Links}} and {{Quotes}} --> |
| + | {{List|title=Libertarians Criticizing Each Other|links=true}} | ||
| + | {{Quotations|title=Libertarians Criticizing Each Other|quotes=true}} | ||
