Difference between revisions of "Liberty"

From Critiques Of Libertarianism
Jump to: navigation, search
 
Line 20: Line 20:
 
liberty must be discussed initially as an individual right.
 
liberty must be discussed initially as an individual right.
  
Freedom is an inherently social concept, devoid of meaning outside of society, whereas the concept of assets (or wealth) is not an inherently social concept.  A man all alone on a planet, with no connections with other moral agents, can hardly be said to be either free or unfree.  He doesn’t live in a free society, just as he doesn’t live in a generous society.  For the same reason, he could not be said to be unfree.  He doesn’t live in a society, at all.  Liberty, like generosity and kindness, refers to a relationship among persons (or at least among moral beings of some sort).  (It may involve other terms, as well, but it is nonsensical to invoke the concept of liberty without invoking a multiplicity of persons.)
+
"Freedom is an inherently social concept, devoid of meaning outside of society, whereas the concept of assets (or wealth) is not an inherently social concept.  A man all alone on a planet, with no connections with other moral agents, can hardly be said to be either free or unfree.  He doesn’t live in a free society, just as he doesn’t live in a generous society.  For the same reason, he could not be said to be unfree.  He doesn’t live in a society, at all.  Liberty, like generosity and kindness, refers to a relationship among persons (or at least among moral beings of some sort).  (It may involve other terms, as well, but it is nonsensical to invoke the concept of liberty without invoking a multiplicity of persons.)"<br>
Tom Palmer
+
[https://www.cato-unbound.org/2010/03/12/tom-g-palmer/liberty-liberty Tom Palmer]
  
 
One man's liberty is another man's slavery.  Often literally: the liberty to own slaves has been a frequent, real world oxymoron.   
 
One man's liberty is another man's slavery.  Often literally: the liberty to own slaves has been a frequent, real world oxymoron.   

Latest revision as of 11:47, 10 November 2020