Difference between revisions of "We understand the Constitution, they do not."
From Critiques Of Libertarianism
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
[[Category:Constitutional Rights and Civil Liberties]] | [[Category:Constitutional Rights and Civil Liberties]] | ||
[[Category:Law]] | [[Category:Law]] | ||
− | {{DES | des = This libertarian attitude shows a profound ignorance of how the law ascribes meaning to documents such as the Constitution. | + | {{DES | des = This libertarian attitude shows a profound ignorance of how the law ascribes meaning to documents such as the Constitution. | show=}} |
<!-- insert wiki page text here --> | <!-- insert wiki page text here --> | ||
+ | |||
+ | First and foremost, the current meaning must take into account all subsequent legislation and court rulings. If I declared the elections of southern representatives to be invalid because they were apportioned too many seats (their black constituents should have been counted as 3/5 according to the Constitution), I would be laughed at because of my ignorance of the 14th amendment. Likewise if I ignore later judicial interpretations. | ||
+ | |||
+ | Second, there must be one shared meaning, which requires social construction. If a libertarian swears that he is reading the meaning "literally", so may anybody else: you still require a social judgement of what the "literal" reading is. If you get as far as deciding that a "literal" reading is the appropriate way to understand the document. | ||
+ | |||
+ | Third, general statements such as those in the Constitution have problems with precision and conflict with other statements in the same Constitution. Those problems have no clear, inerrant solution: they must be resolved by some interpretive authority. The US Supreme Court has arrogated that responsibility in Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803). | ||
<!-- DPL has problems with categories that have a single quote in them. Use these explicit workarounds. --> | <!-- DPL has problems with categories that have a single quote in them. Use these explicit workarounds. --> | ||
<!-- otherwise, we would use {{Links}} and {{Quotes}} --> | <!-- otherwise, we would use {{Links}} and {{Quotes}} --> | ||
{{List|title=We understand the Constitution, they do not.|links=true}} | {{List|title=We understand the Constitution, they do not.|links=true}} | ||
{{Quotations|title=We understand the Constitution, they do not.|quotes=true}} | {{Quotations|title=We understand the Constitution, they do not.|quotes=true}} |