View source for What Is Liberty?
From Critiques Of Libertarianism
Jump to:
navigation
,
search
<!-- you can have any number of categories here --> [[Category:Mike Huben]] [[Category:Liberty|040]] [[Category:Positive Alternatives To Libertarian Ideas]] [[Category:Under Construction]] {{DES | des = Liberty (AKA Freedom), the supposed object of Libertarianism, is hardly ever defined or discussed analytically by libertarians. Liberty, as used by libertarians, is a [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glittering_generality glittering generality of propaganda]: an emotionally appealing phrase so closely associated with highly valued concepts and beliefs that it carries conviction without supporting information or reason. But liberty is susceptible to analysis and that analysis reveals enormous problems with libertarian ideology. | show=}} A good model of liberty should be consistent with observations from law, economics, and anthropology. If it is based on observation, we can call it a positive model, like other models in the sciences. (But not necessarily philosophy.) == Libertarians Gloss Over What Liberty Is == For example: * If you look in [[The Encyclopedia of Libertarianism]] by [[Ronald Hamowy]], there is no entry for liberty. * [[David Boaz]]'s ''[[Libertarianism: A Primer]]'' has only one sentence defining liberty: "liberty itself is the right to make choices and pursue projects of one's own choosing." (p.15.) The rest is preoccupied with examples of liberty, but not what liberty is. His confusion is obvious because he describes liberty as a "right". * [[David Friedman]], in ''[[The Machinery of Freedom: Guide to a Radical Capitalism]]'' does not index liberty or freedom. * Neither does [[Robert Nozick]] in ''[[Anarchy, State, and Utopia]]''. * [[Milton Friedman]], in ''[[Free To Choose]]'', does not define liberty or freedom. * [[Jan Narveson]], in ''[[The Libertarian Idea]]'', writes 9 pages of philosophical handwaving to get to (paraphrased) "A is free to do S if A can choose, but there is possible interference." (pp.13-21.) * [[Jason Brennan]], in ''[[Libertarianism: What Everyone Needs to Know]]'', arbitrarily selects one of the many definitions of "positive" and "negative" liberty, which he defines simplistically in terms of "power to do what one chooses" and "absence of obstacles". (p.26) * [[David Schmidtz]] and [[Jason Brennan]], in ''[[A Brief History of Liberty]], write "Here we categorize forms of liberty as much as our present purpose requires. We don't assume that there is any essence awaiiting our discovery; neither do we assume otherwise." They gloss over [[Gerald MacCallum]]'s [[Freedom as a Triadic Relation]] in a footnote, despite the fact the he unifies liberty with a model and dismisses the positive and negative distinctions the authors prefer. There is no mention of [[Hohfeld’s typology of rights]], and thus they conflate power, rights and liberty. This absence of satisfactory definitions of liberty or freedom is typical of libertarian literature. == Liberty or A Liberty == == A Positive Model Of Liberty == A person (P) is free to do or be a thing (T), receiving a benefit (B), using an ability (A), with a resource (R), when all others (O) do not interfere, despite costs (C), because of reason (B). == Examples That Could Be Explained By This Model == == Positive and Negative Liberty ==
Template:DES
(
view source
)
Template:Extension DPL
(
view source
)
Template:QuoteOne
(
view source
)
Return to
What Is Liberty?
.
Navigation menu
Views
Page
Discussion
View source
History
Personal tools
18.119.109.119
Talk for this IP address
Log in
Search
Search For Page Title
in Wikipedia
with Google
Translate This Page
Google Translate
Navigation
Main Page (fast)
Main Page (long)
Blog
Original Critiques site
What's new
Current events
Recent changes
Bibliography
List of all indexes
All indexed pages
All unindexed pages
All external links
Random page
Under Construction
To Be Added
Site Information
About This Site
About The Author
How You Can Help
Support us at Patreon!
Site Features
Site Status
Credits
Notes
Help
Toolbox
What links here
Related changes
Special pages
Page information
Guidelines To Create
Indexable Page/Quote
Indexable Book/Quote
Indexable Quote
Unindexed
Templates
Edit Sidebar
Purge cache this page