Difference between revisions of "What Is Property?"

From Critiques Of Libertarianism
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 19: Line 19:
  
 
So claims and possession are not enough to establish property.
 
So claims and possession are not enough to establish property.
 +
 +
Posesssion is considered in the legal community to be only one of [#What_are_the_component_rights_of_property.3F a bundle of many rights that comprise property].  You need more than just possession to have property.
 +
 +
==Don't animals have property?==
 +
Often people think of behaviors of animals (such as territoriality) as being indicative of animal property.  Such behaviors are widespread and ancient, arguably even present in bacteria.  Possession is a better description.  While an animal might protect its nest, does it really have  [#What_are_the_component_rights_of_property.3F the other rights that comprise property according to Honoré]?  No.  And with the exception of a very few social species, there is no social enforcement of possession.  Apparently, only humans have property.
  
 
==How is property created?==
 
==How is property created?==
Line 122: Line 127:
 
#Exclusion: The right to determine who will have an access right, and how that right may be transferred.
 
#Exclusion: The right to determine who will have an access right, and how that right may be transferred.
 
#Alienation: The right to sell or lease management and exclusion rights.
 
#Alienation: The right to sell or lease management and exclusion rights.
 
==Do animals have property?==
 
Often people think of behaviors of animals (such as territoriality) as being indicative of animal property.  Possession is a better description.  While an animal might protect its nest, does it really have the other rights that comprise property according to Honoré above?  No.  And with the exception of a very few social species, there is no social enforcement of possession.  Apparently, only humans have property.
 
  
 
==Why don't we have full liberal property rights?==
 
==Why don't we have full liberal property rights?==

Revision as of 13:08, 2 March 2016