View source for Was Medieval Iceland an Example of Anarcho-Capitalism?
From Critiques Of Libertarianism
Jump to:
navigation
,
search
<!-- you can have any number of categories here --> [[Category:Lord Keynes (pseudonym)]] [[Category:Medieval Iceland]] [[Category:David Friedman]] <!-- 1 URL must be followed by >= 0 Other URL and Old URL and 1 End URL.--> {{URL | url = http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2013/06/was-medieval-iceland-example-of-anarcho.html}} <!-- {{Other URL | url = http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2013/06/was-medieval-iceland-example-of-anarcho.html}} --> <!-- {{Old URL | url = }} --> {{End URL}} {{DES | des = "Apparently a real world privatised justice system would require a high degree of equality of power and wealth, which I submit to you is grossly unrealistic." | show=}} <!-- DPL has problems with categories that have a single quote in them. Use these explicit workarounds. --> <!-- normally, we would use {{Links}} and {{Quotes}} --> {{Quotations|Was Medieval Iceland an Example of Anarcho-Capitalism?|quotes=true}} {{Text | Some people appear to believe that it was: “Medieval Iceland is perhaps the closest approximation of an anarchist or libertarian republic that the world is likely to see. Founded in the years between 870 and 930. when its Althing and legal system were established, Iceland was settled by people unwilling to submit to a more coercive and, as the sages describe it, tyrannical Norwegian monarchy.” (Pencak 1995: 1). I will reserve the question of how close medieval Iceland really was to some kind of anarcho-capitalism system for another post. But let us assume, for the sake of argument, that it was. David Friedman (1979) studies the system of private law in medieval Iceland as an example of a real world “privatised” justice system. However, Friedman appears to admit that “public” crimes existed in Icelandic society (a slight difficulty!). Furthermore, as far as I can see, the actual courts seem to have set up in a rather democratic manner as quasi-“public service” institutions, rather than as fee-taking private businesses. But, again, let put these concerns aside for the moment. Iceland had a system of wergild, a private custom and legal procedure by which a murder only results in the perpetrator paying a fine to the kin or family of the victim. I would contend that such a practice means that the rich can literally get away with murder. And, lo and behold!, we read from Friedman himself that this is what actually happened: “A second objection is that the rich (or powerful) could commit crimes with impunity, since nobody would be able to enforce judgment against them. Where power is sufficiently concentrated this might be true; this was one of the problems which led to the eventual breakdown of the Icelandic legal system in the thirteenth century. But so long as power was reasonably dispersed, as it seems to have been for the first two centuries after the system was established, this was a less serious problem.” http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Iceland/Iceland.html I am sorry, but did I read that correctly? The private Icelandic legal system broke down by the 13th century as (presumably) inequalities of power and wealth resulted in just the type of problem critics complain would happen. Apparently a real world privatised justice system would require a high degree of equality of power and wealth, which I submit to you is grossly unrealistic. A final comment on the level of violence in medieval societies. I freely admit that I do not have proper estimates at hand for Iceland, but other evidence suggests that medieval societies were extremely violent by modern standards in the absence of strong state-based law enforcement and widespread private tort law. Friedman himself actually cites a crude calculation of per capita homicide rates in medieval Iceland on the basis of some mere epic fictions, the “Sturlung sagas.” But that is an incredibly naive and unconvincing method of calculating real world historical homicide rates. BIBLIOGRAPHY Friedman, D. 1979. “Private Creation and Enforcement of Law – A Historical Case,” Journal of Legal Studies 8.2: 399–415. http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Iceland/Iceland.html Pencak, William. 1995. The Conflict of Law and Justice in the Icelandic Sagas. Rodopi, Amsterdam and Atlanta, GA. }}
Template:DES
(
view source
)
Template:End URL
(
view source
)
Template:Extension DPL
(
view source
)
Template:Quotations
(
view source
)
Template:Text
(
view source
)
Template:URL
(
view source
)
Return to
Was Medieval Iceland an Example of Anarcho-Capitalism?
.
Navigation menu
Views
Page
Discussion
View source
History
Personal tools
Log in
Search
Search For Page Title
in Wikipedia
with Google
Translate This Page
Google Translate
Navigation
Main Page (fast)
Main Page (long)
Blog
Original Critiques site
What's new
Current events
Recent changes
Bibliography
List of all indexes
All indexed pages
All unindexed pages
All external links
Random page
Under Construction
To Be Added
Site Information
About This Site
About The Author
How You Can Help
Support us at Patreon!
Site Features
Site Status
Credits
Notes
Help
Toolbox
What links here
Related changes
Special pages
Page information
Guidelines To Create
Indexable Page/Quote
Indexable Book/Quote
Indexable Quote
Unindexed
Templates
Edit Sidebar
Purge cache this page